Goldman Sachs Group Inc is in the final stages of resolving its biggest legal threat in a decade after tussling with the government on one critical issue: a potential guilty plea for the first time in Goldman’s history.
To avert such a penalty over its work for sovereign fund 1MDB, Goldman has appealed to the justice department’s highest ranks. The department’s No. 2 official has been directly involved in the case, which has been overseen by Attorney-General William Barr. Barr obtained a waiver because his former law firm represents Goldman.
Now, a deal may be near. Prosecutors were emboldened to press Goldman for a guilty plea after a high-ranking Goldman banker pleaded guilty in 2018 and described a secretive corporate culture that sidelined compliance staff, people familiar with the case said. Since then, Goldman has pushed back on that narrative and secured a hearing from the nation’s top law enforcement officers.
Goldman’s defence is led by Karen Seymour. She was brought in two years ago as general counsel with a mandate to end the years-long US criminal investigation over the billions of dollars Goldman raised for 1MDB. Much of that money was allegedly siphoned by people connected to the former prime minister.
If Goldman escapes without a guilty plea, it will be a big victory for the bank. If not, Seymour may still be able to soften the blow by bartering over what details are included – and not included – in a statement of facts outlining Goldman’s conduct in Malaysia.
Jake Siewert, a Goldman Sachs spokesman, wouldn’t comment on the status of the negotiations. “We are trying to resolve this matter as expeditiously as possible,” he said.
John Marzulli, a spokesman for the US attorney’s office in Brooklyn, New York, that’s handling the case, declined to comment.
Seymour knows from her experience representing Goldman as an outside lawyer that an all-out battle could backfire. The bank tried that approach a decade ago after the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) accused it of fraudulently marketing a mortgage investment known as Abacus that was secretly meant to fail.
Whereas banks typically respond to new investigations with deference and promises to cooperate, Goldman pushed back hard against the SEC action, vowing to defend itself and describing the SEC’s allegations as “completely unfounded in law and fact”. Over several months, the legal exposure and bad publicity lopped almost 25% from the firm’s market value.
At the time, Seymour was a partner at Sullivan & Cromwell, Goldman’s outside law firm, and was dispatched to clean up the mess generated by Goldman’s fighting words. Ultimately, she negotiated a pact with the SEC that included a hefty US$550 million fine but no admission of wrongdoing.
In the 1MDB case, the bank is awaiting word from Department of Justice (DoJ) leaders about whether they agree with their prosecutors in Brooklyn that any deal must include a guilty plea by a subsidiary in Asia, according to a person familiar with the matter. (Prosecutors’ insistence on an admission of guilt was reported earlier by the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal.) A decision would clear the way for a settlement, the person said.
Once the DoJ renders its decision about a guilty plea, a resolution could follow quickly, including a penalty as high as US$2 billion.
The sprawling investigation into 1MDB is the biggest threat to Goldman Sachs since the darkest days of the 2008 financial crisis.
In September of that year, following the collapse of Lehman Brothers and the sale of Merrill Lynch to Bank of America Corp, the Federal Reserve allowed Goldman and Morgan Stanley to convert themselves into bank holding companies, giving them access to the Fed’s discount window and allaying concerns about their viability. The Abacus case grew out of the mortgage meltdown at the centre of the crisis.
In Malaysia, Goldman helped the government raise US$6.5 billion for the 1MDB fund, collecting an unusually high US$600 million in fees from bond sales in 2012 and 2013, according to court filings in the case. Prosecutors allege that roughly US$2.7 billion of that money was diverted to 1MDB officials and their associates.
Prosecutors have received help from Tim Leissner, a former Goldman banker who led the fund-raising for 1MDB. He pleaded guilty to conspiracy to bribe foreign government officials and money laundering. Goldman says Leissner was a rogue actor who deceived his superiors at the bank. Prosecutors appear to have taken a different view, that Leissner was acting in his capacity as an agent of the bank.
Seymour is probably best known for her work as a federal prosecutor in winning the 2004 conviction of Martha Stewart, who made false statements to prosecutors conducting an investigation of her stock trading.
A Texas native, Seymour served as a federal prosecutor in Manhattan in the 1990s before moving to Sullivan & Cromwell. She returned to the office, known as the Southern District of New York, in 2002 to serve as head of its criminal division under then-US attorney James Comey.
Friends and former colleagues say Seymour’s biggest asset in her current role is her history negotiating with the government on behalf of global banks, including Goldman and BNP Paribas SA.
“She is the picture of credibility and integrity,” said Michael Schachter of Willkie, Farr & Gallagher, who was Seymour’s co-prosecutor in the Martha Stewart case. “When you are trying to represent a financial institution in a government negotiation, nothing is more important than making sure the government is able to trust what they’re hearing, and nobody inspires trust in their word like Karen Seymour.”
With Seymour fully engaged in the 1MDB settlement negotiations, Goldman’s CEO David Solomon bolstered the firm’s oversight functions in April, naming former Obama White House Counsel Kathryn Ruemmler as global head of regulatory affairs, overseeing the bank’s compliance department.
The bank is separately negotiating a settlement with Malaysian authorities, who recently said they would reject offers of as much as US$3 billion in contrast to the previous administration that had floated lower figures.