Telling the media to be fair and accurate on the issue that has sparked uproar in the Chinese community, the prime minister says he never said no to UEC recognition.
Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad has denied that he rejected recognition of the Unified Examination Certificate (UEC) due to the sensitivity of the Malay community.
He said this in reference to a recent interview in Sin Chew Daily on the matter, under the title ‘Tun Mahathir: The recognition of UEC needs to consider the feelings of Malays’.
The report has since been picked up by other agencies, including the Borneo Post under the title ‘Feelings of Malays must be considered in recognition of UEC,’ and The Edge Markets with the title ‘UEC recognition has to consider Malays’ feelings: Dr M.’
Following this, MCA and DAP leaders had asked if the prime minister had taken into account the feelings of the Chinese community.
“On the UEC issue, I never said I rejected (it). I merely said there are sensitivities among the Malays on this issue.
“We take into account the sensitivities of all races, including the Chinese, Indians, orang aslis and all ethnic groups in Malaysia.
“If we were not sensitive, then we would not have gotten the support from the people or won (the general election),” Dr Mahathir said during a press conference after chairing the Pakatan Harapan (PH) presidential council on Friday (Jan 4).
Dr Mahathir clarified that when he spoke on the sensitivities of the Malay community, it did not mean that he would side-line the sensitivities of other races or communities.
“I would like to remind everyone that we must take into account the views of all ethnicities, not just one,” he said.
Dr Mahathir said he did not reject interview requests from the media and urged the press to be fair and accurate in their reporting.
“I hope the press will report the truth.
“Although we tried to abolish the anti-fake news law, the attempt failed as we did not get the support of the opposition senators,” said Dr Mahathir.
In the interview with Sin Chew Daily, he reportedly said that the government had to consider Malay sentiments and resolve the issue of unequal wealth distribution between ethnic groups before recognising the UEC.
Some had taken the interview to mean that the prime minister was against recognising the UEC, which had been one of PH’s key election pledges.
“I’m always asked for interviews and I never reject, but sometimes the report that is published is not what I said,” he said.
“On the UEC, I never said I rejected it. I just said there are sensitivities among the Malays about this matter, and we take into account everyone’s sensitivities, including those of the Chinese, Indians, Orang Asli and others.
“If we are not sensitive, we won’t get the people’s support. We must take the views of all races into account, not just one.”
Just because he had said the Malays were sensitive about the matter did not mean that others were not sensitive or that he was not being sensitive either, he added.
In an attempt to set the record straight, the Prime Minister’s Office has since produced an audio recording of the interview.
Based on the audio recording, Dr Mahathir had said that the government will recognise the UEC “to the extent that we can” when asked for assurance for the matter.
The UEC is an examination taken by students in Chinese independent schools.
However, he had stressed that bridging the economic gap between races was more important.
Dr Mahathir also admitted during the interview that PH’s aim to win more Malay support made it more difficult for the government to fulfil its election promise to recognise UEC.
A transcript of the recording with regards to the question on UEC as published by Malaysiakini:
Reporter 1: Just now you mentioned education. In the Pakatan Harapan manifesto, the recognition of the UEC and Chinese independent schools is included. So what is the status of the recognition of the UEC?
Mahathir: That has (inaudible) been stated, we recognise it. I said many times (that) we recognise foreign degrees, we recognise Cambridge certificates, we also recognise the certificates issued by other countries.
But you are asking this to be accepted by the government. To a certain extent, this has already been accepted, but you must have the basic mastery of the Malay language. You see, you must have that.
And the exams should reflect the situation in this country. You can’t take a foreign examination from a foreign country and use that as a qualification. Nobody has done that.
Reporter 2: Tun, actually I’m a UEC holder, I studied in a Chinese independent school. I think the History syllabus was quite contravative (sic) because some of the history we learned is from outside the country, such as, we learned the history of China, world history, but we also studied Malaysian history and we studied the history of Southeast Asia. We are curious why the government until now can’t recognise UEC and why the Malays are so sensitive (about the matter).
Mahathir: Well, the Malays when they agreed to independence, they agreed that non-Malays must also be given citizenship, and indeed they gave more citizenship than people who are qualified, but they believed that by so doing, we will have a country with one language, one culture and basic laws and understanding that are all very Malaysian.
But they found that even the language (inaudible) and all that was not very well supported, and many people until now cannot speak Malay at all, and yet we accept them. I think how much more do you want to ask them to accept?
This country is quite different from other countries. Other countries have got multiracial people, but they speak one single national language.
Reporter 2: So, will Pakatan Harapan’s objective to win over Malay support make its promise to the Chinese community harder to achieve, such as this UEC?
Mahathir: Ya, but we try to meet (the promises), it is not that we don’t. You make a comparison between Malaysia and its neighbours. In other countries, they don’t allow Chinese schools, they don’t allow even signboards sometimes. It is recently only they copied us.
Even if you ask people of Chinese origin in some of these countries, they would like to migrate to Malaysia. They say here they are much more acknowledged as their ethnicity is recognised.
Reporter 1: So Tun, will you give your assurance to the Chinese community the Pakatan government will recognise the UEC, can you give the assurance?
Mahathir: Ya, I think we recognise it to the extent that we can. Look, there are differences – one of the worst differences is the disparity in the distribution of wealth in this country that we have tried to correct.
I admit many of the faults are with the Malays but this one (economic disparity) you don’t correct, and you are always correcting this one only (UEC).
This one is very simple for you to correct – the language or UEC or whatever. That is very simple. That is a stroke of the pen and it is done. But to bring the three races in Malaysia plus the bumiputera in Sabah and Sarawak to the same (level of) economic development takes time.
You know, they feel they are getting less and less. The disparity is not getting less, it is getting more simply, because when we started, it was estimated that the Malays had two per cent of the wealth, the Chinese had 30 per cent and the Europeans (and) foreigners had about 40 per cent.
But when you increase by say 10 per cent, 10 per cent of two per cent is only 0.2 (per cent), but 10 per cent of 30 per cent is three (per cent). So, the disparity is that way and you can see this all around. Who owns these things?
Please remember that in other countries, they riot and they fight, they kill. But in Malaysia, Malays, Chinese and Indians can live and work together. We even absorb some of your cultures, now we use chopsticks.
Reporter 3: But Tun, the government has been helping the bumiputera for more than 60 years, including (during) your time. Why can you still not meet your target or objective?
Mahathir: There are certain weaknesses among the Malays, their culture is wrong. So we want to change that. This time around, we want to change their culture, their value system.
They must work hard, as hard as the Chinese. They must understand that in business, it is important to be honest, to pay your debts – all those things need to be reimplanted into them.
For the old people, no way we can do. We are going to do it in the schools. The minister of education yesterday was telling about the very extensive efforts we are making to change the mindset of the Malays. Once the mindset of the Malays is changed – in terms of ability, they are about the same – but mindset is very important.
My view is that…my observation travelling all over the world is that people succeed or fail not because of race or colour or whatever, or whether they are living in temperate or tropical countries. They fail because of different cultures. For example, Eastern Europeans are not as advanced as Western Europeans, their culture is different.
We see, for example, the Japanese, the Koreans, they are doing well and now the Chinese have become the second biggest economic power in the world. That is related to their culture. The culture of the Chinese – 4,000 years of culture, versus the culture of the Malays, which is basically 600 years old, is not the same and it is because of that that they fail.
The opportunities are there from the very beginning. I am, well, 90 years old and for 70 or 75 years, I have observed the Chinese who came here when I was a boy, they were very poor, working as coolies. (Genting founder Lim) Goh Tong was a coolie, nothing. But their culture drove them to work, to do business and all that, and they succeeded.
Today, they are no longer rickshaw pullers. When I went to school, (I was) being pulled by a Chinese man in a rickshaw… Those days (when) they came, they were very poor, but their children and grandchildren have done very well.
Why they have done very well is of course, because Malaysia offered opportunities for them – at the time, China was in shambles – and they did very well because they seized the opportunities…but the Malays, their culture is laidback.
For example, I told the Malays if there is tin in the ground under your house, you have to dig it before you become rich, but you would rather ask the Chinese to dig it and receive a little bit or something. That is why you fail. You must dig, you must do it yourself.
Related report: Jan 3, MCA, DAP Voice Strong Concerns over Dr M’s UEC Remarks