Rafidah Aziz: Wrong for anyone to call for Thomas’ book ban

367
- Advertisement - [resads_adspot id="2"]

Not wrong for people to have their own interpretation of historical events, especially when it comes from a political perspective.

No one has the right to call for a ban against Tommy Thomas’ book, said Rafidah Aziz.

“Thomas has written his memoir. We may have different views, but that does not give anyone the right to call for banning the book,” the former international trade and industry ministry said in a Facebook post.

The former attorney-general’s memoir titled My Story: Justice in the Wilderness has ruffled feathers after numerous figures named in it, like former prime minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad, former attorney-general Apandi Ali and former prime minister Najib Razak, who disputed Thomas’ version of certain events.

Thomas is also facing investigations after dozens of police reports were lodged against his memoir, while his critics have called for the book to be banned, which has become a bestseller and is awaiting third print.

“It’s a worrying trend when there is no room for dissent, and diversity of views.

“Of course, we cannot condone seditious acts, and libellous actions, but then again, no one has taken real action on some misdeeds, and misinterpretation of facts by some people…although they have gone viral,” Rafidah said.

She said a memoir was a historical account, or biography, based on personal knowledge and the person’s view.

“Sometimes the same thing can be viewed very differently by different people,” she said.

“I don’t want to comment on the legalese as I am not a lawyer but it is important to remember that any person who writes his or her personal memoir cannot be forced to view things from the readers’, analysts’ or commentators’ viewpoints,” she said.

She also questioned why certain quarters were in a rush to take legal action or lodge police reports against the book, or even call for its ban.

“Are we turning into a dictatorship? Are we behaving like cooks in the hot kitchen who cannot stand the heat?” she said.

Rafidah added it was not wrong for people to have their own interpretation of historical events, especially when it comes from a political perspective.

Sharing her own take on the book, Rafidah said she had mixed feelings over the book, including feeling upset, disappointed and a good dose of relief.

“Thomas’ memoir can add to the collection of diverse views on some events of the past. Facts cannot be denied. Do read the book,” she said. – TMI


Related reports:

Feb 9, Tommy Thomas declines to take part in forum on memoir

Feb 8, 134 police reports lodged against Tommy Thomas’ memoir

Feb 8, Tommy Thomas pledges full cooperation with cops over book investigations

Feb 8, Tommy Thomas responds to Najib’s letter of demand over allegations in memoir

Feb 5, Tommy Thomas memoir: Police open two investigation papers, will summon Thomas

Feb 5, Cops quiz publisher of Tommy Thomas’ memoir, Home Ministry scrutinising content

Feb 5, Cradle Fund CEO murder trial: Shafee calls for contempt proceedings against Tommy Thomas

Feb 4, Ex-AG vs ex-AG

Feb 3, JALSOA says Tommy Thomas insulted legal officers in his book

Feb 3, Ex-solicitor-general lodges report against Thomas over unflattering comments

Feb 2, Najib seeks apology, RM10 million from Tommy Thomas

Feb 2, Tommy Thomas: Government lawyers lack drive to excel

Feb 1, Art Harun tells Tommy Thomas not to blame others for his failure to remove the ouster clause in the Elections Act

Feb 1, Sri Ram: Thomas’ disclosures not bound by lawyer-client privilege

Feb 1, Tommy Thomas: UAE prince lobbied Dr M to drop IPIC case in London

Feb 1, Tommy Thomas: Sirul’s evidence corroborated Azilah’s “shoot to kill” Altantuya claim

Feb 1, Tommy Thomas wanted bounty on Jho Low

Feb 1, Tommy Thomas: Coroner’s decision on Adib mind-boggling, defied police evidence

Feb 1, In memoir, Tommy Thomas says Nurul Izzah expressed family’s distrust of Dr M in 2016

Jan 31, Tommy Thomas: Dr Mahathir not keen on expelling Zakir Naik

Jan 30, Report: Tommy Thomas’ explosive memoir blames Mahathir for the implosion of PH

Jan 26, When Tommy Thomas came within a breath of not being A-G